The Story Beneath the Story

People sometimes ask why I keep returning to Boaz.

After all, there are countless small towns across America. Why this one?

The easy answer is that Boaz is familiar. I know its streets, its schools, its churches, its neighborhoods, and the rhythms of everyday life. But familiarity has never been enough reason to write a novel.

The real reason lies deeper.

Every novel I have written begins with a question that has very little to do with plot.

It begins when I wonder what story someone has been living without ever realizing it.

Not the story everyone else sees.

The quieter one beneath it.

A person may think they are protecting their family, when in reality they are protecting a secret that has shaped generations.

Someone may believe they are defending their faith, when they are actually defending an identity they inherited long before they were old enough to question it.

Another may spend years chasing success only to discover they have been pursuing someone else’s definition of a life well lived.

Those are the stories that interest me.

The mystery in my novels is rarely the deepest mystery.

The greater mystery is how ordinary people become so accustomed to the stories surrounding them that they no longer recognize those stories at all.

That is why Boaz matters.

Not because it is unique.

Because it is ordinary.

Small towns have a way of preserving stories. Families hand them down. Churches reinforce them. Schools repeat them. Businesses become part of them. Before long, an entire community begins to assume that life simply works this way because it always has.

Of course, this isn’t unique to small towns.

It happens everywhere.

Boaz simply allows me to watch it up close.

As a novelist, I’m less interested in proving someone wrong than in asking a quieter question:

Who told you this was the only story you could live?

Sometimes the answer changes everything.

I’ve come to realize that this question has quietly followed me through every Boaz novel. The crimes, the secrets, the courtroom testimony, the church conflicts, the family histories—those are not the destination. They are the circumstances that force people to stop long enough to see themselves more honestly.

When that happens, the story changes.

Not because someone else rewrites it.

Because the character finally recognizes the story they have been living all along.

Perhaps that’s why I keep returning to Boaz.

Not because it is a place filled with extraordinary people.

But because it is filled with ordinary people whose lives matter.

People very much like us.

And I suspect that’s why stories matter in the first place.

A good novel doesn’t simply entertain us for a few hours.

It quietly interrupts the story we’re already living.

When we close the book, we return to our own lives carrying a different question than the one we had when we began.

Sometimes that question stays with us.

Sometimes it changes us.

And occasionally, it helps us recognize the story beneath the story.

The Pencil’s Philosophy—From Questions to Stories: A Writer’s Journey

THE PENCIL'S PHILOSOPHY - THURSDAYS
Welcome to The Pencil's Philosophy, my Thursday focus on writing as transformation. Here you'll explore how writing connects to deeper understanding, how questioning leads to growth, and how stories transform both writer and reader. Whether you're seeking truth or finding your voice, these posts guide your journey of discovery.

My journey from certain answers to courageous questions began with a pencil and a blank page. After sixty years of accepting inherited truths, I discovered that writing fiction opened doors to deeper understanding.

Writing demands honesty. When crafting characters, we can’t hide behind comfortable assumptions. Our characters must face hard truths, make difficult choices, and question everything—just as we must do in our own journey of growth.

Today, working on my twelfth novel, I’ve learned that authentic stories emerge from authentic questioning. Each time my characters face a crisis of belief, confront uncomfortable truths, or challenge accepted wisdom, they’re exploring the same territory I navigated in my transformation from CPA and attorney to novelist and story coach.

Three Truths About Writing and Growth:

1. Questions Lead to Stories

Every powerful story starts with “What if?” When we dare to question our assumptions, we find characters doing the same. Their journeys mirror our own search for truth.

2. Stories Lead to Understanding

Through fiction, we explore different perspectives, challenge our beliefs, and discover new ways of seeing the world. Our characters teach us as much as we teach them.

3. Understanding Leads to Growth

As our characters evolve through their stories, we evolve through our writing. Each draft becomes a step in our own transformation.

Your Story Journey:

Whether you’re writing your first novel or your twelfth, embrace the questions that arise. Let your characters challenge comfortable beliefs. Trust that your story will lead you to deeper understanding.

“We write to taste life twice, in the moment and in retrospect.”

– Anaïs Nin

Remember: The truest stories come from the courage to question everything.

Note: If this is your first appointment, you do not have to pay. I offer a FREE—initial consultation.