The People Left Behind

A few days ago, I watched a Netflix documentary about the disappearance and murder of Natalee Holloway, the eighteen-year-old Alabama girl who vanished during a high school graduation trip to Aruba in May 2005.

I remember the case from twenty-one years ago. Like many Alabamians, I followed the news coverage as investigators searched for Natalee and her family struggled to learn what had happened to her. But watching the documentary brought the tragedy into my thoughts again, and I found myself considerably more affected than I expected.

I felt tremendous sadness for Natalee, a young woman whose life was taken just as she was beginning adulthood. I felt disgust and anger toward Joran van der Sloot, the man who eventually admitted killing her. And I was especially moved by what Natalee’s mother, Beth Holloway, endured during the years following her daughter’s disappearance.

I cannot imagine what it would be like to lose a child under such circumstances. Not simply to learn that your son or daughter has died, which would be devastating enough, but to spend years wondering what happened, where the body might be, and whether the person responsible will ever tell the truth.

Beth Holloway spent years searching for answers. She endured false leads, deception, and the terrible uncertainty that accompanies the disappearance of someone you love. Even after van der Sloot admitted killing Natalee in 2023, her daughter’s remains were still missing.

As I watched the documentary, I kept thinking about what those years must have been like for Beth and her family.

Twenty-one years have passed since Natalee disappeared. Think of everything that has happened in the world during those years. Children have grown into adults. Families have celebrated weddings, births, graduations, and countless ordinary occasions. People have moved, changed careers, grown older, and experienced the thousands of events that make up a human life.

Natalee was denied those experiences.

And the people who loved her have had to live through those same years without her.

I think that’s what affected me most.

We often hear about murder through the circumstances of the crime itself. We learn about suspects, evidence, investigations, confessions, and trials. We wonder who committed the crime, how it happened, and whether the person responsible will be punished.

Those are important questions. But there’s another part of the story that receives less attention after the headlines fade.

What happens to the people left behind?

That question was still troubling me when my thoughts turned to a novel I’ve recently begun developing.

The Boaz Skeleton is the second mystery featuring Connor Ford, a fictional investigator whose stories take place in and around Boaz, Alabama. The novel begins with the discovery of skeletal remains concealed inside an old house. The discovery raises questions about a disappearance nearly thirty years earlier.

I’ve been working on the circumstances surrounding the disappearance, the people involved, and the mysteries Connor will need to unravel. Like any novelist developing a murder mystery, I’ve been concerned with creating a compelling investigation, believable suspects, unexpected developments, and a resolution that satisfies readers.

But after watching the Holloway documentary, I found myself thinking more seriously about someone who may never have seemed particularly important to the mechanics of the mystery.

The missing man’s mother.

In my developing story, David Bellamy disappeared nearly thirty years ago. His body was never recovered. His family eventually held a memorial service, but the coffin was empty. There were no remains to bury.

His mother has lived all those years without knowing what happened to him.

Until recently, I had given more attention to the mystery of David’s disappearance than to what his absence might have meant to the people who loved him.

That’s something I need to reconsider.

What does thirty years of uncertainty do to a mother? How does she manage the ordinary responsibilities of living while carrying questions that never go away? Does she eventually stop expecting answers, or does some part of her continue hoping that someone, somewhere, knows what happened?

I don’t yet know how my fictional mother would answer those questions. I haven’t spent enough time getting to know her.

But I suspect that understanding her experience could become important to the story.

There’s an obvious difference between Beth Holloway and a character I create in a novel. Beth is a real person who has endured an actual tragedy. Her daughter’s murder is not a fictional event, and I have no desire to appropriate that suffering or reproduce the circumstances of Natalee’s death in a mystery novel.

What the documentary did was remind me of something that should matter whenever I write about murder.

The crime doesn’t end when the victim dies.

Its consequences continue through the lives of people who loved that person. A mother may spend years searching for answers. A father may struggle with anger or regret. Brothers and sisters may grow older while carrying memories of someone who never had the opportunity to grow older with them.

And those consequences cannot necessarily be undone by identifying the person responsible.

I want The Boaz Skeleton to be an absorbing mystery. I want readers to become involved in Connor Ford’s investigation, to consider the evidence, suspect the wrong people, and eventually discover a truth they didn’t anticipate.

But I also want the people in the story to matter.

The discovery of a skeleton may be an intriguing beginning for a novel. For a family that has spent thirty years wondering what happened to someone they loved, such a discovery could mean something altogether different.

It might bring relief. It might reopen terrible wounds. It might expose secrets that have remained buried for decades. And it might force people to confront truths they would rather never have learned.

Those are possibilities I’m only beginning to explore.

One of the things I’ve come to appreciate about writing fiction is that ideas sometimes arrive from experiences having nothing directly to do with the story I’m developing. A conversation, a memory, something I’ve read, or a documentary I’ve watched can cause me to reconsider a character or recognize an aspect of a story I’ve neglected.

That doesn’t mean the experience becomes part of the plot. Sometimes it simply changes the questions I ask as I write.

Watching the documentary about Natalee Holloway hasn’t given me a new murder mystery. Nor has it provided answers to the questions I’m developing in The Boaz Skeleton.

But it has made me more conscious of the suffering that can exist beyond the central crime.

I began this novel with an old house, a concealed skeleton, and a disappearance that occurred nearly thirty years ago.

Now I’m thinking about a mother who has lived through those thirty years.

I don’t know her very well yet.

But before I finish writing her story, I intend to.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Richard L. Fricks

Richard L. Fricks is a novelist and Fictionary Certified StoryCoach Editor living near Boaz, Alabama. His fiction explores ordinary people caught in difficult human questions, and he works with a small number of beginning novelists through a year-long, in-person writing program.

Leave a Reply