After stirring the chili, I walked outside into a cool but gorgeous blue-sky day. I stared at the barn, the five goats nudging the fence, and the pond beyond, before checking the doors on my Explorer. I had no good reason to believe they had somehow come unlocked, but I had to verify. Last night I’d left the pistol in its plastic bag laying underneath the floor mat behind the driver’s seat. I’d stuffed the diary and Bonhoeffer’s book inside my briefcase and brought them inside to the bedroom of my youth, tiptoeing to avoid waking Kyla, who I assumed was sound asleep in her upstairs bed.
I went inside and poured a cup of lukewarm coffee from Kyla’s automatic maker that had already turned itself off. After nuking it for forty seconds, I almost returned to the front porch, but given the temperature, opted for the kitchen table. I was glad I had this time alone to organize and digest the things I’d learned from yet another one of Rachel’s diaries. This one, found stuffed inside a wall for who knows how long.
I don’t know why, but last night, lying in my old bed, I read Rachel’s last entry. It was dated Saturday, December 27, 1969. Now, more alert, I fetched it from my bedroom, returned to the den, and again flipped to the back. “In two days, I will fly with my family from Atlanta to Miami, and from there, sail to Hong Kong, along with the baby turning and kicking inside me.” I was still as much in shock as I had been at 2:00 a.m. this morning.
Since I hadn’t brought the diaries from Rachel’s basement library, confusion set in. My memory was cloudy, but before I set foot on Alabama soil, I would have bet her abortion had taken place while she was still living in Alabama. Now, the latest diary stated the very opposite. Had Rachel lied to me?
After her first suicide attempt, she told me the reason she had tried to kill herself was because of an abortion at age 16. During the months after her disclosure, I’d fought my way to acceptance, concluding teenagers do stupid things; I chalked her sex, pregnancy, and abortion to youthful indiscretion.
Maybe I had read between the diary lines or subconsciously created facts that didn’t exist. But one thing now appeared true. The diary I was holding laid out Rachel’s account of her last thirty days as a tenth grader at Boaz High School. Two other things I felt were correct. This diary and the pistol had been inside the wall since shortly before Rachel returned to Hong Kong in December 1969. However, the Bonhoeffer book had joined its companions in the not-so-distant past. The reason I believe the latter to be true is that Rachel had written notes that strongly suggested she had made them after her first suicide attempt. Somehow, during the six months before she hanged herself, November 29, 2019, she had traveled to Boaz and visited the Hunt House. Then I realized there might be another option. What if Rachel had given The Cost of Discipleship to someone else and that person had hidden it inside the wall?
I raided Kyla’s refrigerator for a bottle of grape juice and changed mental gears. What I’d learned early this morning about Kyle Bennett was even more shocking.
In all the years we’d been friends, I’d never known he was greedy or opportunistic. That assessment had changed whether Rachel’s diary was trustworthy. Somehow, Kyle had learned about her pregnancy. Rachel had expressed confidence Kyle’s source had come from Dr. Harold Malone’s office. Kyle’s mother worked for him as a nurse. Kyle and Kent often took the bus there after school.
With his newfound knowledge, Kyle had concocted a plan, one that would eventually (so he thought) enable him to purchase a car. Even though Kyle, like me, was a half foot shorter than Ray Archer and a hundred pounds lighter, he presented a demand for $500.00 in exchange for his silence. Apparently, at first, Ray kept his cool, even seeking Rachel’s advice. This negotiation had ended with Ray borrowing the money from his father (the ruse being Ray needed the money to buy Rachel a ring) and giving it to Kyle. Per Rachel’s stipulation, Kyle had signed a document she had prepared that acknowledged his promise of confidentiality, and that Ray had paid him in full for his ‘knowledge.’
Kyle’s second demand took only a week: “one-thousand dollars by Thanksgiving.” This demand revealed my friend’s naivety and stupidity, illustrating he was unaware of the risks he was taking. Albeit Ray’s hair-trigger temper and superior strength.
To Rachel’s surprise, Ray again paid the money. This time sweet-talking Arlene Baker, his father’s bookkeeper, for a ‘short-term’ loan. After Ray tendered the money to the conniving Kyle, he expressed his anger at Rachel and acknowledged their near-hopeless situation. “This shit won’t ever end (Ray was sometimes short-sighted).” He pleaded with Rachel to do something. “Use your smarts and figure out a way to convince Kyle this has to stop.”
By the morning of Friday, December 12, the day of the Boaz Christmas Parade, Ray had given up on Rachel’s intelligence and creativity. Just as she had written in one of her basement diaries, she and Ray had taken care of Kyle after removing the PA system from the tenth-grade float.
Ray had shot and killed Kyle. But, unlike the basement diaries, the walled-off diary provided additional details. After dropping off the PA system at First Baptist Church of Christ, with Kyle sitting between Ray and Rachel on the bench seat of his 1968 step-side Chevrolet pickup, he had driven to a farm his father owned off Cox Gap Road. It was a subterfuge. Ray shared his intent to give his 1964 Ford Mustang to Kyle in exchange for his eternal silence and that, “tonight was as good a time as any to show off the red fireball.” According to Rachel, Ray’s father had bought the car directly from the factory and it was one of the first ever to be built by Ford Motor Company.
Once Ray turned right onto Dogwood Trail, Kyle started fidgeting, like he’d just had a rude awakening. He offered to refund the money and asked to be let out of the truck. Ray laughed. In a mile, he turned left onto an old logging road and wound his way beyond a barn and to a clearing next to a pond. Ray had parked, gotten out of the truck, leaving Kyle and Rachel sitting. During this time, Kyle had asked why they had stopped and where the Mustang was. In less than a minute, Ray was back. Rachel opened her door and exited the vehicle. Ray ordered Kyle to slide on the seat and come to him, all the while pointing the Smith & Wesson at Kyle’s head.
Ray had walked a shaking and nervous Kyle to the edge of the pond and ordered him to keep walking and never come back. Kyle had screamed, cried, and begged Ray to forgive him and save his life, again promising to return the money. Ray had shot two times, the first hitting the water ten feet from the shore. Rachel didn’t know if this was simply a bad shot or a tease to terrorize Kyle even more. The second blast hit Kyle in the head, at the base of the skull. He was dead before his body hit the water.
I closed my eyes and lifted my head. In my thirty-eight years as an attorney, I’d read countless murder cases appealed to a higher court. Everyone sets out facts determined at trial. Everyone involved a victim, all horrible situations, some more terrorizing than others. Now, my mind changed forever. The victim in this case, my best childhood friend, had experienced mental trauma I wouldn’t wish on the most horrible person I could imagine. Then, it hit me, this was no appeals case on behalf of the murderer. No defendant existed or ever argued for a directed verdict or a new trial. In Kyle’s situation, there had never been a trial. There had been no justice of any kind for my dearly departed friend. For half a century, the brutal and evil billionaire enjoyed unlimited freedom. Tossing and teasing justice like a cat terrorizing a mouse.
I stood and walked to the front porch. It seemed colder than it had an hour earlier. I sat in Kyla’s swing and started audibly repeating the same word. “Why, why, why?” Why would it have mattered if Ray and Rachel disclosed the commonly occurring facts? Why would they take such drastic steps to keep them secret? Why did they value their future, which was uncertain, over the life of a fellow human being, one they should have considered a friend?
The answer I kept getting had something to do with Rachel’s abortion. The lawyer in me couldn’t stay still. What if Rachel admitted her abortion to Ray, but that had been a lie? If the last entry in the walled-off diary was true, Rachel was pregnant with Ray’s baby the day she left with family to return to Hong Kong.
I became nauseated when another thought crossed my mind: what if Kyle knew more truth than he’d shared with Ray? What if Kyle knew Rachel had lied to Ray about her having the abortion?
And more nauseating still: what if Rachel herself was an accessory to Kyle’s murder? Doing more than simply hide the Smith & Wesson? Again, if she had written the truth, she had done nothing to stop Ray. Couldn’t she have warned Kyle? Somehow? Couldn’t she have talked Ray out of his evil intent?
I dug myself deeper into my hole of confusion. I stayed there until I heard Kyla’s truck crunching gravel as it left McVille Road headed my way.

















































by 



by 